North Carolina, United States
Casual seafood dining in Reidsville, NC with steamed, fried, and broiled fish, steak, pasta, and local specialties. Dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup available.
4.3 / 5
Guest rating
1,955
Reviews
Seafood Restaurant
Cuisine
North Carolina
City
$10–20
Price level
Closes at 9:00 PM
Mayflower Seafood Restaurant offers a down-to-earth dining experience with a variety of seafood dishes including steamed, fried, and broiled fish, along with steak and pasta options. The atmosphere is casual, cozy, and quiet, creating a relaxed setting for solo diners, families, and groups.
Located at 1641 Freeway Dr. in Reidsville, North Carolina, this restaurant serves local specialties and features highlights such as great coffee and tea selections. Guests typically spend between 15 minutes to an hour per visit, enjoying lunch or dinner with table service and seating indoors.
Signature dishes, shareable plates, and the items regulars keep coming back for.
Grouped by category — each group lists what's available and what isn't at Mayflower Seafood Restaurant.
When Mayflower Seafood Restaurant is open during the week.
Closes at 9:00 PM
Central North Carolina, with cafes, shops, and other restaurants within easy walking distance.
A look at the food, the dining room, drinks, and the exterior of Mayflower Seafood Restaurant.
What recent guests say after dining at Mayflower Seafood Restaurant.
Based on 1,955 guest reviews
lisa barnes
Jun 29, 2026"I have been eating at this Mayflowerbin Reidsville ever since I was a child. The food has always been great. One year we had my Grandmother's birthday party there, she loved it. If you ever come to Reidsville stop in because it's a great place to eat!"
Jenn Ladale
Jun 16, 2026"We had a late lunch here, it was around 3:30-4pm on a Saturday, and they were kinda busy but I have seen it packed up like sardines on a Sunday afternoon right after church. No wait for a table, the waiter was amazing, got our orders right and checked on us several times throughout the meal. The salt & pepper catfish was freaking awesome, their chicken tenders are almost the best I've ever had, and believe it or not they have ACP that tastes better than what the Mexican restaurants around town serve you, no BS! If you like the ACP meals, do yourself a favor & order it from here at Mayflower, trust me y'all!! (By the way, the service has always been absolutely the BEST service than any restaurant in town, EVERY SINGLE TIME! As long as you get one of the guy waiters)"
Lloyd Janney
May 19, 2026"Looking for a family friendly great tasting food and affordable prices,look no futher then Mayflower seafood. You'll be amazed at how great everything really is. And the decor makes you feel your at sea. The srivce is quick, and friendly. You find that affordable family dish that won't break your bank."
D Perry
Apr 24, 2026"Good food, good service. Friendly atmosphere. Plenty of parking. If you love seafood, this is the place to go."
J Z
Apr 13, 2026"With a pleasant, casual atmosphere, super nice employees, and fresh, delicious seafood, this is my favorite place to eat in Reidsville! One of the things I like the best about this restaurant is that the menu offerings are not complicated. You can just get one type of seafood, fried or broiled, or can get combinations of several, with less hidden calories than food at some fancy seafood restaurant chains. We ordered broiled jumbo shrimp, and a combo of broiled flounder, shrimp, and oysters, with sides of fresh salad, mouth-watering hush puppies, and large baked potatoes, and all the food was very satisfying. The portions were generous for the amount of money charged. Our super nice, attentive server (the one who moved there from Florida) really cared about making sure our dining experience was great. The colorful, beachy décor on the wall created a relaxing environment. Nice place!"
Common questions about visiting Mayflower Seafood Restaurant in Reidsville, NC.
The menu features steamed, fried, and broiled seafood dishes, steak, pasta, salads, and local specialties. Popular items include fried shrimp, seafood combos, crab cakes, and captain’s specials.
Yes, there is wheelchair accessible parking, entrance, restrooms, and seating available to accommodate guests with mobility needs.
Reservations are not accepted. Seating is available on a first-come, first-served basis, and busy times can lead to a wait.
Mayflower Seafood Restaurant offers dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup services. Delivery is not available.
Credit and debit cards are accepted, along with NFC mobile payment options.
Yes, the restaurant provides a kids’ menu and high chairs, making it suitable for families with children.
The restaurant serves lunch and dinner, with table service and indoor seating offered. Dessert options are also available.
Parking options include a free parking lot, free street parking, and a paid parking lot nearby.
Keep your listing accurate by updating your address, opening hours, menu, photos, and contact details. Reach more diners searching for Seafood Restaurant in North Carolina on Locallya.
